BAKIT HINDI MARNELLA? : Why Janella and Marlo Weren't Cast in the 'I Love You Since 1892' TV Adaptation

Uncover the real reasons behind Janella Salvador and Marlo Mortel's absence from the I Love You Since 1892 TV adaptation. Learn about dissolved contracts, talent agency dynamics, and executive decisions.


Understanding the Buzz: Why Fan Favorites Weren't Chosen

The news of an I Love You Since 1892 (ILYS1892) TV adaptation has sent ripples of excitement through its dedicated fanbase. However, a significant question has emerged: why weren't fan favorites Janella Salvador and Marlo Mortel, often affectionately referred to as "MarNella," chosen to play the lead roles?

Rumors and discussions have been swirling, and we've gathered insights from showbiz insiders to shed light on this intriguing development. It's important to note that this information is based on credible sources, though for confidentiality, their names will not be disclosed.

The ABS-CBN Factor: A Change of Hands

One of the primary reasons traces back to the publishing rights of the ILYS1892 books. Initially, these books were published under ABS-CBN. However, with the closure of ABS-CBN's broadcast operations, many signed titles and planned TV series adaptations under their wing were shelved. Among these was allegedly the contract for ILYS1892.
When a major media entity like ABS-CBN faces such a significant change, it leads to a turnover of contracts, including those for adaptations and talent. This presented an opportunity for other production houses.


Viva's Acquisition and Talent Roster

According to our sources, Viva Entertainment ultimately acquired the rights to I Love You Since 1892. This acquisition is a crucial piece of the puzzle. Viva, like any production company, prioritizes its roster of signed talents for major projects, especially adaptations.
Here's where MarNella comes into play: Janella Salvador and Marlo Mortel are currently under Star Magic, a different talent agency, and are not part of Viva's roster of artists. This fundamental difference in talent representation makes a significant impact on casting decisions.
The industry practice is clear: when a company invests in intellectual property like ILYS1892, they leverage their in-house talent first. This streamlines production, strengthens their artists' careers, and optimizes their investment.

Executive Decisions and Creative Direction

While many fans might believe that the author's preference should dictate casting, the reality of showbiz adaptations is often more complex. The author, no matter how much they might advocate for specific actors, ultimately does not hold the final say in casting.

The decision-making process for lead roles is an executive one. It's driven by a combination of factors, including the production house's talent pool, strategic business objectives, and the perceived ability of chosen actors to carry the roles effectively. It's about introducing new talents and fresh faces, not solely about fan-casting, though fan engagement is certainly considered.

In the case of ILYS1892, the executive decision was to push talents under Viva's wing. This isn't a reflection on MarNella's talent or their immense popularity among fans; rather, it's a strategic move to utilize and promote Viva's own artists.

The Bottom Line

The contract with ABS-CBN was effectively dissolved, paving the way for Viva to acquire the rights. With Viva now in control, and with their significant executive power and financial backing, they opted to cast actors from their own talent pool.

This is a common practice in the entertainment industry, especially concerning adaptations where rights and talent contracts become intertwined.
While it's understandable for fans to feel disappointed, these decisions are rooted in the business realities of showbiz – an investment in rights, a focus on in-house talent, and strategic executive choices that shape the final product.

No comments:

TRENDING

eat bulaga TV5 TVJ dabarkads Philippine Entertainment Entertainment News abs-cbn vic sotto entertainment Philippine Television Showbiz News opm GMA Network Noontime Show news piolo pascual I Love You Since 1892 kapatid the kingdom trending Philippine TV gma kapamilya Philippines it's showtime jose manalo maine mendoza mmff singing queens Anniversary Atasha Muhlach Celebrity News Filipino Music Music Noontime Showbiz TAPE Inc. TV5 Shows VIBE alden richards aldub awards joey de leon mvp tape inc television tito sotto Filipino Celebrities Filipino Culture Gimme 5 Heaven Peralejo ILYS1892 Legit Dabarkads Online P-pop Philippine Cinema Philippine Media Pinoy Entertainment Ratings TV Ratings Trending News Variety Viva One Wattpad coco martin eb babe legit mquest ppop react vice ganda Andres Muhlach Anne Ferrer Ashdres Ashtine Olviga Barangay Henyo Binibining Mia Cast Reveal Celebrity Updates Digital TV EntertainmentNews Estafa Case Eunice Janine Events Exclusive FPJ's Batang Quiapo FPJ’s Batang Quiapo Filipino TV Frontline Pilipinas G22 Grand Winner Hong Kong It’s Showtime Janella Salvador Jean Drilon Jerome Ponce Joseph Marco KDrama Kalyeserye Khayzy Bueno LMTV Digital Legal News Livestream Madlang People MarNella Marlo Mortel Maxie Andreison Miles Ocampo Noontime Shows Nora Aunor Paolo Ballesteros Philippine Independence Day Philippine Showbiz PhilippineTV Pinoy Celebrities Pinoy Music Pinoy TV Pop Culture Sam Rascal Showtime Smart Communications Sugod Campus Taglish News Tawag ng Tanghalan Vibe PH Viva Entertainment Wally Bayola apt apt entertainment arjo atayde batang quiapo bgyo bossing vic sotto ca child star christine reyes christmas id commentary concert csid f4 jowapao kim chiu mediaquest meteor garden movie mzet papa p queen amber torres rtc sid lucero sue ramirez sugod bahay teleserye the big dome viva 1621 1st.One 2025 Programming 2025 Updates 3rd Quarter 2025 46th Anniversary 53rd Box Office Entertainment Awards 98 Degrees ABS-CBN Music ABS-CBN Shutdown ABSCBN ALLTV AMBS ASAP Acting Debut Actors Adaptation Adie Adline Andres Advertisers Advertising Trends Affordabox AlDub Library Allan K American Artists in Manila Ana Ramsey Antipolo Cityhood Anniversary Antipolo Concert Antipolo Events Antipolo History Artist Development Asian Drama Asian Pop Atasha Muhlach Projects August August 2025 Awit Awards 2025 Bad Bad Genius The Series Balitang Showbiz Barangay Champions Batang Quiapo Season 7 Bayanihan Bb. Mia Best TV Station Bossing Vic Box Office Entertainment Awards Boy Bands Breaking News Brgy. Palangoy Broadcast Industry Broadcasting Business and Branding Buy 1 Take 1 Call for Participants Campus Activities Campus Tour Carren Eistrup Casting Celebrations Celebrity Interview Celebrity Life Celebrity Romance Certified Dabarkads Channel 36 Charity Projects Charts Christian Shows Cignal Cignal Play Cignal TV Cinemo Cityhood of Anti Claire Dela Fuente Comedians Community Community Service Concert 2025 Concerts Court Cases Crown Artist Management Cultural Event Cultural Heritage Cup of Joe Current Affairs DDS Reactions DMMMSU DMMMSU-NLUC Dabarkads 2025 Dabarkads Highlights Dabarkads Holy Week Episodes Debt DigitalCitizenship DigitalMedia Dingdong Dantes Dionela Disinformation Dreamscape Entertainment Duterte Administration Dylan Menor EAT EB Dabarkads Eat Bulaga Lenten Specials 2025 Eat Bulaga Singing Queens EatBulaga Education Ely Buendia Encantadia Chronicles Sangg're Entertainment History Entertainment Industry Eraserheads Events Philippines F4 Reunion FILSCAP Awards Faith News Faith-Based Content FakeNews Family Feud Philippines Fan Convention Fan Engagement Filipino Filipino Actress Filipino Adaptation Filipino Artists Filipino Children Filipino Cinema Filipino Drama Filipino Festival Filipino Film Filipino Films Filipino Girl Group Filipino Influencers Filipino Legends Filipino Series Film Restoration Foreignoy Franchise Renewal Francis John Rosas Free Concert Gary Valenciano Gen Z Stars General Manager Genius Gilbert Duavit Glaiza de Castro Grand Champ Grand Finals Hello Heaven Himala Historical Drama Historical Romance Holy Monday EB Holy Tuesday Eat Bulaga Holy Wednesday EB Holy Week Special Holy Week Specials Ian Manibale Iligan City Inspirational Series Inspirational Stories Intellectual Property Jazharra Ungui Jean Jordan Abina Jed Madela Jericho Rosales Jerrold Tarog Jerry Yan John Lloyd Cruz Jon Timmons Jose Ma. De Leon June 2025 June 25 KBP KBP Golden Dove Awards KPop Kapamilya Channel Kapamilya Online Live Kapatid Network Kapatid Shows Kapuso Network Kapuso Stars Karen Carpenter Ken Chu King of Pop Kontrobersiya Kuya Germs La Union Laro ng Barangay Lead Actors Legacy Legal Cases Legal Updates Lenten Special Lenten Special 2025 Lenten Specials 2025 Leo Katigbak Lifetime Achievement Award Lily Little Miss Philippines Live Music Event Live Performance Live Stream Views Livestream.io Local Celebrities Local Entertainment Local News Love Story Lucky Robles MIKE TUVIERA MOA Arena Maja Salvador Mall Tour Malou Choa-Fagar Malou Fagar Manny V. Pangilinan Manuel L. Quezon March 2025 Events Matt Monro May 30 2025 Mayday Concert McDonald's Mandaluyong Media Awards Media Center Media Collaboration Media History Media Innovation Media Launch Media Ownership MediaLiteracy Messenger voting Meteor Rain Michael Jackson Milestones Minamahal Most Promising Artists Movie News Movie Preservation Music Awards Music Chart Music Countdown Music History Music Industry Music Reunion Music Show NTC Order Nasaan Si Atasha Network Infrastructure New Host New OPM Artists New Shows News and Current Affairs News5 Nielsen Ratings Noontime Ratings NoontimeShow Now OFW News OPM Artists OPM Female Clones OPM News OPM countdown Oh Baby Online Bashing Online Filipino Programs Online Live Views Online Viewership OnlineViews PBB Collab PCMC PEP.ph PLDT PMPC Star Awards PMPC Star Awards Eat Bulaga PPL Entertainment PTV-4 Pambansang Bae Pan Paolo Contis Para Sa Isa't Isa People's Television Network Peter Dizon Philippine Advertisers Philippine Cu Philippine En Philippine Entertainment News Philippine Game Show Philippine Movies Philippine Music Philippine News Philippine Noontime Show Philippine Noontime Shows Philippine Politics Philippine Series Philippine Superstar Philippine Trademark Philippine literature Pilita Corrales Pilot Episode Pinoy Pinoy Faith Pinoy Memes PinoyMusic Plastic ni Juan PlayTime Popular TV Program Power voting Press Freedom Primetime Primetime Drama Primetime Shows Public Service Queen Amber Torres Update Quezon Movie REVILLAME RPTV Channel 9 Rabin Angeles Rachel Clemente Radio Recasting Relationship Reunion Rob Deniel Rochelle Santos Romance Romeo Jalosjos Rouelle Cariño Ryzza Mae Dizon SMS voting School Supplies Drive September2025 Series Adaptation Settlement Offer Sharon Cuneta Showbiz Controversy Showbiz Culture Showbiz PH Showbiz Updates Sing Galing Sing-lebrity Edition Singing Competition Singing Queens EB Smart Smart Araneta Coliseum Smart Multi SIM Social Media Reactions Sold Out Concert Sparkle GMA Spolarium Star Awards 2025 Star Cinema StarPop Stories from the Heart Streaming Streaming Era Student Events Student Life Studio Viva Sugar Mercado Sugod Mall Mga Kapatid TBA Studios TV Adaptation TV Sales TV Series TV Show TV Show Highlights TV Shows TV Update TV executive TV5 Channel Guide TV5 Iligan TV5 Network News TV5 Trending TV5 Updates TVJ (or relevant production group/network) TVJ Studio Taglish Tahanang Pinakamasaya Taiwanese Boy Band Talent Fee Issue Tamang Panahon Tatak EB Tatak Eat Bulaga Technology That’s My Bae The Clones ThinKaMunaPilipinas Top 10 Trending Love Teams Trending PH Tribute Tributes Tulong Pinoy Una Sa Lahat University Events Upcoming Movies Uplifting Stories VAA Vanness Wu Vibe voting VibePH Vic Chou Views Viral Questions Viva Artists Viva Artists Agency Viva Records VivaOne Vivarkada WILLIE Watchapp Wattpad WEBTOON Studios Willie Revillame Wowowin Ynares Center YouTube Streaming Youth Volunteers ad revenue ambernation anak tv analog anna ramsey appeals araneta atasha baby amber bagong pilipinas barbie hsu big screen bini bir book news book sellers book warning bossing box office buko dela cruz bulaga campus cedrick juan children christmas commentaries competition court da pers family darryl yap dds digital divina law duterte eSIM engaged espantaho esquire face to face franchise frontline gabriel government news handa na ako hapon champion hardbound books history hold me close holiday iWant iWantTFC incognito intellectual ipo ipophl issues its showtime jalosjos judicial judy ann santos julia barreto julia montes kalayaan kapuso lala sotto legal lorna tolentino magazine makabata malaya maranan marcos marikina media news mergene mergene maranan mtrcb muhlach new GM new release new year ninang amber noli de castro overpriced books ownership paano bumoto party pasko pbbm pcc pepsi paloma pilipinas premiere night property rbonney review rights sponsors station id studio sugod taiwan tape tax tinatwa topakk trial tuviera tv patrol vhong navarro vicor viewership viral voting guide wedding wil to win yayadub zephanie zion cruz